Fayetteville Police Department
Be The Badge Logo

city seals


Press Releases
Released: 5/28/2010 Who do I contact? Dan Grubb
Public Information Officer
(910) 433-1896
Fayetteville Police Department

The Fayetteville Police Department has identified and issued warrants for arrest for the following subjects in this case. The three women are charged with Misdemeanor Assault and Misdemeanor Larceny for their role in the assault and theft at the Hobby Lobby store on 4/27/2010:


·        Candice Nicole McCall, 27, of 115 Oak Tree Drive in Raeford, NC

·        Mytaza McPhaul, 18, of 141 Utah Drive in Raeford, NC

·        Shanika Andrews, 28, of 920 Johnson Street in Raeford, NC


The Fayetteville Police Department would like to thank the public for the numerous tips received regarding the identity and whereabouts of the three women. Please see attached mug shots for McCall and Andrews.

Shanika Andrews

Candice Nicole McCall


Copyright © 2015, City of Fayetteville, Police Department. All Rights Reserved.
467 Hay St. · Fayetteville, NC 28301
Send Us Comments | Privacy Statement | Web Accessibility (Section 508) | ADA Compliance